Friday, July 15, 2005

Powerful

From Sarah :

And so this evening i decided to walk abouts my neighborhood, find a cafe and study for the GREs before it got too dark. Not really know what direction I was heading, I stumble upon a beautiful mosque..

finally I found one in my neighbor, near by, one I could attend for Friday prayer.. I try to enter the mosque but its gated, and I’m not really sure where to go, so a man leads me towards the entrance. Realizing im not from around (because I couldn’t understand what he was saying) he proceeds to find out where the women’s section is (if there is one). Alas, he points behind a green curtain and tells me to pray in there.

I walk in …to find a peaceful older looking women who smiles at me as I walk in. a green curtain eH? Subannalah, the call to prayer is elevated by a loud speaker as soon as I walk in. I wait for them to begin prayer, and I step outside the curtain.

And I pray.

Enjoying the beauty of the creation that god has allowed. A beauty that is rarely seen in the US, as most mosques are old converted buildings, especially in the university setting..

I ask from god the normal things, of health happiness and peace, and walk out the masjid, only to start tearing as I think about the green curtain. Why was that man so insistence that I pray behind it? How can such a beautiful religion allow for something so unjust, how can a religion who elevated a former slave and allowed him to recite the first call to prayer be the same religion that places women behind a dark shield.. a shadow..

I know It isn’t so..

As I walk, the man who assisted me earlier questions as to why I didn’t pray behind the curtain as he had instructed. Why I disobeyed his orders as if he was the determining factor on judgment day. He then asked whether I understood him (in English) and how Islamic rulings state that women cannot be seen. I simple said, I do not understand and walked in the opposite direction (towards my house)

I know it isn’t so.

Tears role, as I am torn. Imagine for a moment, a women who gives birth to a man. A man who is then given money..by the grace of god …to build such a fascinating piece of architecture to be enjoyed by ALL of society. Would he in his sane mind, place his mother, the women who gave him life, behind that green embroidered curtain? What kind of sanity is that…

If I wanted to pray on a hilltop, in the grass, in the park when the call to prayer was heard, would I be placed behind a curtain? My entire world is grounds for prayer..how is it that a formal structure actually built for prayer is forbidden for me?

How is it that I cannot enjoy the beauty of the khutab on a Friday afternoon, of the passionate preacher voicing his sermon, or enjoy the gold Arabic calligraphy around the mosque, or the delicate detail paintings or the massive pillars which hold the building up.. why am I not able to enjoy the building that came from a women, who gave birth to a man, that could build the mosque…

I know it isn’t so,

but how could this man be so naïve..

8 Comments:

Tamer Zikry said...

This post has been removed by the author.

5:04 PM  
Tamer Zikry said...

Religions are being interpreted differently...

Religions boast having a monopoly on the truth...

Islam boasts to be the religion of tolerance, equality and co-existence...it might be on some levels but then it is not what it boasts...

Islam boasts being a religion for all times...well might be a problem of interpretation but then some aspects of Islam are not necessarily suitable for all times...

No religion holds a monopoly on the truth...

Just the two cents of a liberal Sunni Muslim (at least think I am)

5:05 PM  
Jenna V said...

...beautiful...

5:38 PM  
AcappellaFella said...

Is this practice (to make women pray behind a curtain) a tradition in egypt or certain parts of the world? or is it actually part of the religion, as written in sacred texts or what not?

9:56 AM  
Tamer Zikry said...

Women in Islam should pray in lines behind the men in the same space...its more or less cultural in Egypt (and I have also seen it in Kuwait) that the women pray behind a curtain...or in some cases in a completely separate room...

3:06 PM  
gannat said...

Dear sarah,
I totaly understand your feelings that it is your right to enjoy the mosques as mens do but you can look to it from another point of view that in our religion mens shouldn't see womens while they are praying that's why you will find in almost all mosques that the prayer area for mens is seperated from those of womens even here the mosques have the same style so it is not a culutral thing & the only place that mens & womens can pray aside is in mekkha, i'm not sure if you agree with me or not but you can ask a sheikh if you want but what i know for sure that womens shouldn't be seen while they are praying....
from my point of view if half of the mosques is made for womens on the same level of architectural beauty than we would acheive an optimal solution where you can enjoy the mosque while applying our rules.
Waiting for your comment

9:31 AM  
SherifDaBeef said...

I'm from New York. We have many masjids and of all types. Apartments revamped to whole buildings converted to the 96st mosque that was built to be a mosque. In some of the mosques nobody really has a good view, but the one on 96th st. is actually very nice and the women pray on a balcony in the back up stairs and overlook the rest of the mosque. I've never been up there, but as a kid, I remember thinking that the girls were so lucky! Also I see no reason why women should pray behind a curtain. I'll settle for in line behind men, but that's it. In this scenario at man would have to as he is praying in his segouia (spelling) would have to make a counsious effort to look back to see a woman and the fault is on him! that's the way I see it.

12:39 PM  
Monica said...

i am a christian who has stumbled upon your webpage. salaam project sounds so powerful. i am sure people of all faiths (especially women) have questions about why some rules are what they are. but maybe men wonder about things too, like why must men be circumcised? does god give *brownie points* to people who uphold the rules but have hate in their hearts? my heart tells me that at the core of faith is the idea to protect and preserve people. if we are secure in that, why must we hate and kill those who are different? the biggest threat is greed for money and power, not people who have the love of god within their hearts. when we truly love god, we will love mankind. if we love mankind we will be patient and even suffer with one another rather than cause suffering to each other. thank you for posting your thoughts. i respect your ideas and believe in time we will create a better world as long as we keep talking, and even arguing - as even family members do - because that is far better than killing. salaam.

2:57 PM  

Post a Comment

<< Home